Thanks for all your kind word, needed some morale
Linda, the problem with treats is he won't take them on the move so he isn't interested in treats while I am trying to get him to heel!! Annoying to say the least, I should perhaps try walking with a ball but then he would jump up at me for it!!
We won't use a halti anymore since we perservered to get him used to it for a week or two until he scraped his nose across the concrete to try and get it off, he then came up bleeding!! At that point I refused to have him wear it again so he has been training on a flat collar and nothing more.
I may have explained badly as it is not our test tonight, just a normal class! But still very fed up with it lol, every week I have to push myself to go!
I am very pleased I am not the only one having a nightmare!!
Anni, I wish we could have gone to a GSD only one however, it is dangerous, Dan gets very broody over GSDs lol xx